1 Overture / Take That Look Off Your Face
2 Let Me Finish
3 So Much to Do In New York
4 First Letter Home
5 English Girls
6 Capped Teeth and Caesar Salad
7 You Made Me Think You Were In Love
8 Capped Teeth and Caesar Salad (Reprise)
9 So Much to Do In New York, Pt. 2
10 Second Letter Home
11 Unexpected Song
12 Come Back With the Same Look In Your Eyes
13 Take That Look Off Your Face (Reprise)
14 Tell Me On a Sunday
15 I Love New York / So Much to Do In New York, Pt. 3
16 Married Man
17 Third Letter Home
18 Nothing Like You've Ever Known
19 Finale / Let Me Finish (Reprise) / What Have I Done? / Take That Look Off Your Face