While by Our Sleeping Flock We Lay / Jingle Bells / Caroling, Caroling (Reprise)

1 Caroling, Caroling / Carol, Brothers, Carol
2 The Star Carol / Rise up Shepherd An' Foller
3 O Come All Ye Faithful / Come Dear Children
4 Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town
5 While by Our Sleeping Flock We Lay / Jingle Bells / Caroling, Caroling (Reprise)
6 O Hearken Ye / Christmas
7 Jesu Parvule / Gesu Bambino
8 I Wonder as I Wander / Silent Night
9 O Holy Night / Finale: We Wish You a Merry Christmas