The Lie

You and I
A story from another time
About a soul caught in between and a love unknown to me
Saw me standin' by the sea
Watched the waves wash over me
And they played "Dancing in the Moonlight", it was all there ever was

And I tried, and I tried
And I told you, "Yes, until we die"
Somethin' old and somethin' new
And a promise to be true, but I lied

Nightingale
The truth was just too hard to tell
I wish you'd never made me feel these tears pourin' over me
Dreamed about an open sky
One that only youth could find
And it was bright, and it was new, it was perfect just like you

And I tried, and I tried
And I told you, "Yes, until we die"
Somethin' old and somethin' new
And a promise to be true

And I tried, and I tried
And I told you, "Yes, until we die"
Somethin' old and somethin' new
And a promise to be true, but I lied

Yes, I lied
Yes, I lied