1 You There in the Back Row (13 Days to Broadway)
2 I'm Gonna Wash That Man Right Outa My Hair (South Pacific)
3 Since You Stayed Here (Brownstone)
4 Knowing When to Leave / Promises, Promises (Promises, Promises)
5 Where Is Love? (Oliver!) [feat. Billy Porter]
6 Meadowlark (The Baker's Wife)
7 Sleepy Man (The Robber Bridegroom)
8 Our Time (Merrily We Roll Along) [feat. Ann Hampton Callaway]
9 I Got the Sun in the Morning (Annie Get Your Gun)
10 Stop, Time (Big)
11 One Boy (Bye, Bye Birdie)
12 Marry Me a Little (Marry Me a Little)
13 The Story Goes On (Baby)
14 A Place Called Home (A Christmas Carol)
15 Where Do I Go from Here? (Fiorello!)
16 New Words (In the Beginning)
17 Everybody Says Don't (Anyone Can Whistle)
18 I Remember (Evening Primrose)
19 What Am I Doing Here? (Promises, Promises)
20 Nothing More to Say (Stars On My Shoulders)
21 One of the Beautiful People (No Way to Treat a Lady)
22 Run, Run, Run Cinderella (Foxy)
23 Goodbye for Now (Reds)