1 Tears at the Birthday Party
2 The Sweetest Punch
3 Toledo
4 Such Unlikely Lovers
5 This House Is Empty Now
6 Painted from Memory
7 What's Her Name Today?
8 In the Darkest Place
9 Vamp Dolce
10 My Thief
11 I Still Have That Other Girl
12 Painted From Memory (Reprise)
13 The Long Division
14 I Still Have That Other Girl (Reprise)
15 God Give Me Strength